In the Spirit of Critique: Thinking Politically in the Dialectical Tradition (SUNY Series in Contemporary Continental Philosophy)

By Andrew J. Douglas

Bargains a brand new point of view at the political value of the Hegelian dialectical legacy. targeting the severe postures of Hegel, Marx, and a chain of twentieth-century intellectuals, together with Sartre, Adorno, and C. L. R. James, this publication explores what dialectical considering includes and the way such pondering may communicate to the lived realities of the modern political second. what's published isn't really a proper procedure or a grand philosophical method, yet particularly a reflective power or disposition—a dialectical spirit of critique—that attracts normative sustenance from an emancipatory ethical imaginative and prescient yet that continues to be attuned largely to clash and stress, and to the tragic uncertainties of political existence. In gentle of the original demanding situations of the late-modern age, as theorists and voters fight to maintain an energetic and coherent severe time table, within the Spirit of Critique invitations severe reconsideration of a wealthy and elusive highbrow culture.

Show description

Quick preview of In the Spirit of Critique: Thinking Politically in the Dialectical Tradition (SUNY Series in Contemporary Continental Philosophy) PDF

Similar Political Theory books

From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology

An advent to the paintings of the best German sociologist and a key determine within the improvement of present-day sociological idea.

Republicanism: A Theory of Freedom and Government [Oxford Political Theory Series]

This can be the 1st full-length presentation of a republican substitute to the liberal and communitarian theories that experience ruled political philosophy in recent times. the most recent addition to the acclaimed Oxford Political idea sequence, Pettit's eloquent and compelling account opens with an exam of the normal republican belief of freedom as non-domination, contrasting this with verified unfavourable and optimistic perspectives of liberty.

Traveling Back: Toward a Global Political Theory

We are living in an international age, an age of great scale and velocity, an age of serious technological and fiscal and environmental switch, in stipulations our ancestors may well infrequently have imagined. What does this compression of geographical and temporal scale suggest for our political considering? can we desire new modes of political suggestion or a brand new form of political mind's eye?

Scales of Justice: Reimagining Political Space in a Globalizing World (New Directions in Critical Theory)

Till lately, struggles for justice proceeded opposed to the history of a taken-for-granted body: the bounded territorial kingdom. With that "Westphalian" photograph of political house assumed by way of default, the scope of justice was once not often topic to open dispute. this day, despite the fact that, human-rights activists and overseas feminists sign up for critics of structural adjustment and the area exchange association in not easy the view that justice can in basic terms be a family relation between fellow electorate.

Additional resources for In the Spirit of Critique: Thinking Politically in the Dialectical Tradition (SUNY Series in Contemporary Continental Philosophy)

Show sample text content

Eleven And to show the dialectic correct facet up, to place it on its toes, as Marx's famous word might have it, is just to stress that dialectical conflicts and resolutions are continually already prefigured through the given stipulations of fabric fact. In a feeling, Marx desires just to qualify the scope and the philosophical import of the Hegelian dialectic. If “relations of construction represent the industrial constitution of society, the true origin, on which arises a criminal and political superstructure and to which correspond certain types of social consciousness,” and if “it isn't the cognizance of fellows that determines their life, yet their social life that determines their consciousness,” as Marx says in his recognized 1859 preface to A Contribution to the Critique of Political economic climate, then the dialectic, understood in its demystified and rational shape, is yet a way to reveal and clarify the contradictions that plague, now not fabric truth or nature itself, however the “general means of social, political and highbrow lifestyles. ”12 In different phrases, we nonetheless fight to generate a self-conscious and sustainable figuring out of our right dating to fact and to each other, because the Hegelian dialectic may have it, yet for Marx those struggles pan out on the point of the superstructure, that is to assert that those struggles, those methods which are delivered to mild via dialectical mirrored image, are constantly already prefigured by means of extra basic fabric stipulations, via the sum overall of the kin of construction. thirteen to make sure, Marx states explicitly that his “dialectical approach is, in its foundations, not just various from the Hegelian, yet precisely contrary to it. ”14 i'd argue that during phrases of its relation to fact it might probably inverted, grew to become onto a cloth footing, yet when it comes to its constitution, its shape, it truly is now not all that diverse. 15 Marx attempts to differentiate himself from Hegel via suggesting that, for him, “the excellent is not anything however the fabric global mirrored within the brain of guy, and translated into kinds of thought,” and but those “forms of idea” are however acknowledged to spread in a dialectical style. sixteen those types of idea are acknowledged to be marred via deep contradictions, which, as such, are teased alongside by way of the promise of reconciliation. 17 after all the tale is way extra complex than this, and as we flip to Hegel we'll think of how, for instance, noticeable struggles for autonomy and self-determination, struggles opposed to alienation and estrangement, should be acknowledged to ask a dialectical mode of study. this is often precise for either Hegel and Marx. yet right here in the beginning, i need just to recommend that Marx's outspoken attack on Hegelian idealism threatens to imprecise the level to which Marx embraces the basic constitution of dialectical pondering because it surfaces in Hegel. Marx's criticism approximately Hegelian “mystification” is in many ways easily a rhetorical procedure, a reminder that dialectical conflicts play out on the point of realization, on the superstructural point, and that, as Hegel both did not see or maybe easily underemphasized, this superstructure, this dialectical unfolding of self-consciousness, is basically conditioned via a deeper fabric origin.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.24 of 5 – based on 37 votes