Democracy and the Foreigner

By Bonnie Honig

What may still we do approximately foreigners? may still we attempt to cause them to extra like us or preserve them at bay to guard our democracy, our tradition, our future health? This problem underlies age-old debates approximately immigration, citizenship, and nationwide id which are strikingly correct this day. In Democracy and the Foreigner, Bonnie Honig reverses the query: What difficulties could foreigners resolve for us? Hers isn't a standard procedure. rather than lauding the achievements of person foreigners, she probes a far greater issue--the symbolic politics of foreignness. In doing so she exhibits not just how our debates over foreignness support shore up our nationwide or democratic identities, yet how anxieties endemic to liberal democracy themselves animate ambivalence towards foreignness.

Central to Honig's arguments are tales that includes ''foreign-founders,'' during which the origins or revitalization of a humans depend on a foreigner's power, advantage, perception, or legislation. From such well known video clips as The Wizard of oz., Shane, and Strictly Ballroom to the biblical tales of Moses and Ruth to the parable of an immigrant the United States, from Rousseau to Freud, foreignness is represented not only as a probability yet as a complement for groups periodically requiring renewal. Why? Why do humans inform tales during which their societies are depending on strangers?

One of Honig's so much outstanding conclusions is that an appreciation of the position of foreigners in (re)founding peoples works neither exclusively as a sophisticated nor a nationalist source. for instance, in the US, nationalists see one archetypal foreign-founder--the naturalized immigrant--as reconfirming the attract of deeply held American values, while to cosmopolitans this immigrant represents the deeply transnational personality of yankee democracy. students and scholars of political conception, and all these inquisitive about the dilemmas democracy faces in accommodating distinction, will locate this booklet wealthy with invaluable and stimulating insights.

Show description

Preview of Democracy and the Foreigner PDF

Best Political Theory books

From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology

An creation to the paintings of the best German sociologist and a key determine within the improvement of present-day sociological notion.

Republicanism: A Theory of Freedom and Government [Oxford Political Theory Series]

This is often the 1st full-length presentation of a republican substitute to the liberal and communitarian theories that experience ruled political philosophy in recent times. the newest addition to the acclaimed Oxford Political concept sequence, Pettit's eloquent and compelling account opens with an exam of the conventional republican belief of freedom as non-domination, contrasting this with tested unfavorable and confident perspectives of liberty.

Traveling Back: Toward a Global Political Theory

We are living in an international age, an age of tremendous scale and velocity, an age of significant technological and fiscal and environmental swap, in stipulations our ancestors may possibly hardly ever have imagined. What does this compression of geographical and temporal scale suggest for our political considering? can we desire new modes of political concept or a brand new type of political mind's eye?

Scales of Justice: Reimagining Political Space in a Globalizing World (New Directions in Critical Theory)

Until eventually lately, struggles for justice proceeded opposed to the heritage of a taken-for-granted body: the bounded territorial country. With that "Westphalian" photo of political area assumed through default, the scope of justice used to be infrequently topic to open dispute. at the present time, even though, human-rights activists and foreign feminists subscribe to critics of structural adjustment and the area alternate association in hard the view that justice can merely be a family relation between fellow voters.

Extra resources for Democracy and the Foreigner

Show sample text content

At play with the transitional item, the topic acts out her bereavement and is thereby empowered for separation and individuation (as within the “fort-da” game—a form of peek-a-boo—described by way of The Foreigner as Immigrant sixty seven Freud). there's empowerment right here, not only mourning: the play offers the topic now not easily with a alternative (for the loss being mourned), yet with a lesson in what Peter Sacks calls “the very ability and perform of substitution. ” At top, the topic learns organisation within the face of loss (perhaps at the same time as a result of the it, if the stipulations are correct for the sort of learning). eighty four If those stipulations aren't met, neither mourning nor empowerment will take place. as an alternative, the topic will first make a fetish of the article, attractive it in a livid and hyperbolic play that indications her denial of her loss. moment, the thing will finally lose all which means for the topic, and he or she will abandon the article fullyyt, leaving it stranded. The evacuation of the object’s which means can lead to “signification trauma,” which leaves the topic stranded, silent, and speechless, outdoors the area of language, play, and mourning. Emphasizing all 3 dimensions of transitional item play—mourning, empowerment, and intersubjectivity—Santner summarizes Winnicott’s view with the aphorism, “Mourning with no team spirit [i. e. , transitional item play within the absence of intersubjective witnessing] is the start of insanity. ”85 (Her personal bills to psychoanalysis [albeit to not Winnicott] clarify why Kristeva describes what she sees as immigrants’ failed transition when it comes to speechless autism and depression. ) How may perhaps this account practice to the ebook of Ruth? If profitable transitions are decided now not via the character of the transitional item itself yet by means of the context within which it operates, then we needs to attend to the function of associations, tradition, neighborhood, and politics in initiatives of transition, whatever Kristeva doesn't do in her critique of immigrant particularism. additionally, Santner’s specialize in mourning, empowerment, and intersubjectivity calls consciousness to the truth that none of those 3 parts of profitable transition is on the market to Ruth. Ruth’s separation from Orpah (who, on my account, personifies Moab) is irritating, now not transitority. there is not any fit house for transitional item play, no intersubjective witnessing, and no threat of right mourning simply because Ruth isn't given cultural, juridical, or mental permission to mourn Orpah-Moab. Nor are we. Ruth made the perfect selection. Ozick and Kristeva agree on that. What may possibly there be to mourn? Ozick and Kristeva either appear to imagine that their affirmation of the rightness of Ruth’s selection (and their marginalization of Orpah) is what sixty eight bankruptcy 3 secures Ruth’s transition from Moab. yet, if Santner and Winnicott are right, the other is correct: Naomi’s strength as a transitional item for Ruth is determined by the correct mourning of Orpah, even upon a type of endured (perhaps hyphenated? ) relation along with her (Ozick makes a circulation during this course while she says we must always “pause” over Orpah, yet she then hurries correct on previous her), even upon spotting that Orpah (Moab) is a part of Ruth.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.11 of 5 – based on 33 votes